Why You Should Teach Stargirl by Jerry Spinelli in Your Middle School ELA Class

Published in 2000, Stargirl is a young adult novel that quickly gained acclaim for its unique storyline and memorable characters. The novel is set in the fictional town of Mica, Arizona, and follows the life of Leo Borlock, a high school junior who becomes fascinated by a new student named Stargirl Caraway. Stargirl's eccentricities, from her unusual attire to her habit of serenading classmates with her ukulele, make her an instant subject of intrigue and, eventually, controversy.

Here are 10 reasons to incorporate Stargirl into your middle school ELA curriculum:

1. It’s All About Embracing Individuality

• Stargirl is a great way to get students thinking about what makes them unique and why that’s something to celebrate, not hide. In a world where fitting in feels like everything, this book reminds them it’s okay to stand out.

2. Tackles Bullying and Peer Pressure

• Let’s face it, middle school can be tough when it comes to fitting in. Stargirl opens the door for important conversations about how we treat each other and why it’s so important to stand up against bullying and peer pressure.

3. Great for Class Discussions

• There’s so much to unpack in Stargirl—from popularity to kindness to social isolation. It’s perfect for getting students talking, thinking, and engaging with big ideas that really matter.

4. Interesting Characters and Perspectives

• The characters in Stargirl aren’t just your typical teens; they’re complex and relatable. Students can really dive into understanding why characters act the way they do, which makes for some pretty interesting discussions.

5. Opportunities for Creative Projects

• With a character as quirky and creative as Stargirl, the possibilities for fun projects are endless. Whether it’s writing from a character’s point of view, creating art, or coming up with an alternative ending, there’s plenty of room for creativity.

6. Relatable Real-World Issues

• The struggles Stargirl faces—like fitting in and standing up for what’s right—are super relatable for middle schoolers. The book helps them see how these issues play out in their own lives, making it really relevant.

7. Easy to Read, But Deep Enough to Challenge

• Spinelli’s writing is easy to follow, but the themes are deep enough to get students thinking critically. It’s the perfect balance for middle school readers who are ready to dig a little deeper.

8. Encourages Self-Reflection

• Stargirl naturally gets students reflecting on their own lives and how they treat others. It’s a great way to spark conversations about self-awareness and being true to who you are.

9. Builds Empathy and Compassion

• By seeing the world through Stargirl’s eyes, students learn to empathize with others who might be different from them. It’s a great way to teach compassion and understanding in a very real, relatable way.

10. Promotes a Positive Classroom Vibe

• Teaching Stargirl can really help create a positive classroom culture where kindness and acceptance are at the forefront. It’s a great way to set the tone for a supportive, inclusive environment.

Want some resources to jump-start your Stargirl novel study? Be sure to check out my resources!

Have questions about how to implement a Stargirl novel study with your class? Comment your questions below! 💚